Debate: How Should Unions Deal With Free Riders?

Credit: American Association of University Professors, CC 2.0

The U.S. is quickly becoming an open-shop country. A majority of states now have “right-to-work” laws, and the Supreme Court’s decision in Janus v. AFSCME is likely to make right to work the law of the land in the public sector. Many unions are bracing for an immediate exodus of dues- and fee-payers.

In a right-to-work setting, workers have the option to be free riders, receiving the benefits of unionization without paying membership dues or fees. Yet the duty of fair representation requires the union to represent everyone in the bargaining unit, even non-members. This duty arises from a union being the exclusive representative of a group of workers—no other union or organization can speak for them.

Those are the rules in the private sector, anyway. In the public sector, certain states already allow some form of “members-only unions.” In Florida, for instance, public sector unions are not obliged to represent non-members in grievances. The same is true for teacher unions in Tennessee, where multiple organizations compete to represent teachers in the same workplace.

The anticipated Janus decision has sparked a debate. Should public sector unions try to get “members-only” laws passed? Where such laws are in place, should unions really stop representing non-members?

These questions aren’t hypothetical. In April, New York state passed a law, backed by the AFL-CIO, that public sector unions no longer have to provide representation to non-members in disciplinary hearings, grievances, or arbitrations.

Meanwhile national anti-union groups are promoting a similar idea for their own reasons.

Below are links to several perspectives Labor Notes readers sent in. Want to join in the debate? Email us at editors[at]labornotes[dot]org.

Comments

roy120rahul | 07/21/20

Howdy, If you need any help in technical support regarding Office Setup, Garmin.com/express, Linksys Extender Setup, Belkin Router Login, Norton Login, Mcafee Login, Netgear Router Login and Magellan Roadmate Update then you can visit our website and contact us for better support.
Regards -

office.com/setup | Garmin.com/express | Linksys Extender Setup | Belkin Router Login | Norton Login | Mcafee Login | Netgear Router Login | Magellan Roadmate Update

VeronicaMedlin | 07/17/20

office.com/setup - Microsoft Office provides the benefit of word processing, PowerPoint presentation, spreadsheets, newsletters, broachers, Notes, Publisher, and creating various office-related data. It is widely used in various offices, institutions such as schools, colleges, etc. It is compatible with all the available Operating System platforms across the world. The process of installation and activation of MS Office is straightforward so that every user can avail of the benefits of this dynamic application for modifying and designing their documents.

MS Office is the primary application for generating data for various clerical as well as official tasks. Visit the site www.office.com/setup for getting the complete setup of MS Office.

VeronicaMedlin | 07/17/20

office.com/setup - In the digital era everyone is engaged in their digital life and wants to create the best of their tasks through digital equipment, MS Office provides a number of attractive office tools that serve as the assistance for office-friendly applications. These Office suite programs help the users and big corporate to manage their official works through drafting and designing the data effortlessly.

MS Office has a complete set of instructions and guidelines for creating various Office files, projects, and presentations, ranging from corporate sectors to homes. One can download the antivirus and activate its subscription at www.office.com/setup. Follow the guided indications at office.com/setup for support related to the set up operations.

VeronicaMedlin | 07/17/20

office.com/setup - Microsoft has provided several applications to its users for making things easily accessible. One of the best used and widely accepted programs is “MS Office.” It manages various tools that are being used in corporate fields to homes. It works on almost the operating systems, be it Windows, Android, iOS, or Mac.
MS Office contains several programs, such as MS Word, MS Access, MS Excel, MS PowerPoint, etc. It is notably used for various official and formal purposes such as data collecting, graphing, Excel spreadsheets, Word files, presentations, and much more.
One can get the complete set of this program effortlessly by browsing www.office.com/setup. If any query about the program, the user may visit office.com/setup.

packwoods | 07/16/20

Giving up exclusive rep cedes the battleground to the yellow dog contract and company “unions”. Florida teachers unions compete with non-adversarial “associations” aka front groups for the Kochs. Truth is the decision is in the courts’ hands not the unions. We will al
https://packwoods.net/shop/

alfitomorgan23 | 07/14/20

Download and install norton with product key on Windows and Mac. Create an account, sign in and download Norton antivirus. In this era of digital work, antivirus is necessary to keep your device safe. Norton can secure your device, data, online work, identity, network, and others.
installing norton with product key | install norton with product key | www.bullguard.com is-install-mdl-install | garmin.com/express |
www.office.com/setup |
www.norton.com/setup |
www.mcafee.com/activate

alfitomorgan23 | 07/14/20

One of the renowned tech-giant in today's time is Microsoft. Microsoft Office is available in different versions such as Office 2019, Office 365, Office 2016, Office 2013, Office 2010, and Office 2007. It is one of the best software suite for any PC.
www.office.com/setup |
office.com/setup

StephenJones | 07/13/20

hey, i am stephen technical advisor visit my top antiviruss websites:
We give technical support administrations to fix your available to come in to work issues. Call our Executive Customer Support. Our Engineering Support group will get you in contact. As we have settled a large number of Computer/Network issues with superior rate and Rates of consumer loyalty. Proficient help is one of the Leading Generation's most online emotionally supportive networks. We offer quality types of assistance anyplace, any place we utilize the web.
BT Mail
Magellan GPS Update
Garmin Express
office.com/setup
Rand Mcnally Dock Update
TurboTax Login
Mywifiext
Garmin.com/express
Mcafee.com/Activate
turbotax-download
garmin-nuvi-update
office-setup
office-login
rand-mcnally-dock
rand-mcnally-update
randmcnallydockupdate.com/blogs
BT Email Login
BTinternet Login
BTinternet Email​
mcafee-login
mcafee-product-key​
Mywifiext.net Login
Mywifiext.net Login
Mywifiext.net Login
Netgear Extender Login
Netgear Extender Setup
Netgear Login
Netgear Router Login
RouterLogin Netgear
RouterLogin Netgear
www.mywifiext.net
www.routerlogin.net
www.routerlogin.net Setup

ningauble3020 | 08/04/18

Giving up exclusive rep cedes the battleground to the yellow dog contract and company “unions”. Florida teachers unions compete with non-adversarial “associations” aka front groups for the Kochs. Truth is the decision is in the courts’ hands not the unions. We will al
ways have fewer dollars than the Chambers of Commerce. We have the better weapon though: we are fighting for the most noble causes of liberte, egalite, and fraternite/sororite. You can’t buy solidarity. It can only be earned in class war.

RichardGraham | 05/07/18

This issue actually has a very easy solution, but some union executives don't seem to like this idea for some reason. In short, if unions just require 'member only' contracts the Forced Riders will go away. How hard it that?